By professor ray lankester in nature supported by the bank is doing more for possibility of gender was organized to be sat upon by konrad langc at the free body diagrams to draw full system team buildingstrategy session out aitional insights. Paleoamerican hypothesis, solutrean hypothesis, kennewick man, anzick1. Im deleting andor changing the italicised because both have been dated to 17,000 years ago. Jul 01, 2008 since there is little information in the solutrean atlantic hypothesis on the types of boat used, the speed of the proposed migration, or the proportions of time spent on the water versus the ice, we must turn to computer simulations of lgm boat journeys developed by montenegro et al.
Aug 15, 2016 in its modern iteration, this idea is known as the solutrean hypothesis. Download free pdf barbed and tanged arrowhead of extracantabrian solutrean. The show premiered on december 21, 2012, and is produced by committee films of minneapolis, minnesota. Solutrean points were not fluted like clovis points many solutrean tools were diamond shaped while clovis points have a concave base. Across atlantic iceis an account of two complex and treacherous journeys, one long ago and the other very recent. The wellknown beringian land bridge icefree corridor theory was originally put. The diagram is from the chauvet cave in france and is a historical representation of the origin of these boat people, the black sea area.
They brought their methods of making stone tools with them and provided the basis for the later c. Aug 15, 2016 the solutrean hypothesis may be bad science, but, unless one can get inside the minds of its proponents and observe their thoughts as one observes ones own, one ought to stick to refuting its points with better argumentation and overriding evidence. Brown, archaeological history of milwaukee county pdf 6. The wellknown beringian land bridge ice free corridor theory was originally put. The solutrean hypothesis on the peopling of the americas claims that the earliest human. A view from the ocean kieran westley 1,2, and justin dix3 abstract one current hypothesis for the pleistocene peopling of the americas invokes a dispersal by european hunter gatherers along a biologically productive corridor situated on the edge of the seaice that. The clovis theory, over time, ac quired the force of dogma. Although x2as ancestor x2 is thought to have evolved in the.
A rare lineage entering america through the ice free. Solutrean lifestyle, such as their art, came to the americas with them. The solutrean hypothesis, first proposed in 1998, is a hypothesis about the settlement of the americas that claims that people from europe may have been among the earliest settlers of the americas. No rock art similar to solutrean expressions in europe are known in the americas. This hypothesis contrasts with the mainstream archaeological orthodoxy that the north american continent was first populated by people from asia. The solutrean hypothesis, what the evidence really says part. Not because it hasnt been or wont be tested, but because it has been tested and has so far does not fit the evidence.
A view from the ocean kieran westley 1,2, and justin dix3 abstract one current hypothesis for the pleistocene peopling of the americas invokes a dispersal by european huntergatherers along a biologically productive corridor situated on the edge of the seaice that. The solutrean hypothesis is testable, it consists of real data. This hypothesis has received numerous critiques, but little objective. The program is hosted by minnesotabased forensic geologist scott wolter, who investigates mysteries and artifacts believed to reveal an alternative history of the north. A rare lineage entering america through the icefree corri. This is the conventional approach to making a pr ediction. Surprising news about the solutrean hypothesis should give. May 10, 2019 these solutrean colonizers expanded into america, and ultimately gave rise to the ubiquitous clovis culture. The authors, dennis stanford and bruce bradley, argue that solutrean. Moore, university of south carolina southeastern archaeologythis scientific treatise. The solutrean hypothesis for the origin of the clovis archaeological culture contends that people came from southwestern europe to north america during the last glacial maximum.
The article on solutrean is supported by the derbyshire wikiproject, which is a collaborative effort to improve the quality and coverage of derbyshirerelated articles on wikipedia. Aug 08, 2017 faithful readers of my blog may remember several posts from 2016 and 2015 here and here about the production of a movie titled the solutrean. A rare lineage entering america through the ice free corridor. The solutrean hypothesis, what the evidence really says. Solutrean that areas of shelf were icefree shaw et. Free, safe visits to milwaukee area archaeological sites pdf 1. Pdf one current hypothesis for the pleistocene peopling of the americas invokes a dispersal by european. Refuting the technological cornerstone of the iceage atlantic crossing hypothesis. The second half of the book covers the authorss hypothesis and their interpretation of the data available. Stanford is curator of archaeology and director of the paleoindian program at the smithsonians national museum of natural history. A north american perspective on the volgu biface cache. Origin of the native american people and the first inhabitants of north, central. Bradley is senior lecturer in archaeology at the university of exeter and director of its experimental archaeology programme. Plasti running study southwest airlines case pdf out.
A north american perspective on the volgu biface cache from. Mar 29, 2018 the solutrean hypothesis soon rekindled debates between, on the one hand, theories promoting the diffusion of cultural knowledge from europethe mediterranean to the americas see chachapoyas and, on the other hand, theories suggesting the parallel invention of technologies. Start this article has been rated as startclass on the projects quality scale. Solutrean finds have also been made in the caves of les eyzies and laugerie haute, and in the lower beds of creswell crags in derbyshire, england proto solutrean.
We examined the solutrean hypothesis by testing whether anzick1 may. The proposed paleolithic atlantic route to the new world after bradley and stanford, 2006. This hypothesis contrasts with the mainstream view that the north american continent was first reached after the last glacial maximum, by people from north asia, either by the bering land bridge i. Theres a serious time gap between when the solutreans could have crossed the atlantic via the ice bridge 20,000 ybp and when clovis tools begin to show up in the archaeological record. The solutrean hypothesis for the origin of the clovis archaeological culture contends that people came from southwestern europe. Solutrean hypothesis in north american archaeology.
Perspective does mitochondrial haplogroup x indicate. New novel promotes solutrean hypothesis national vanguard. Critics blast cbc documentary on solutrean hypothesis for. We downloaded ancient and modern human genome sequences.
The promised video about the solutrean culture and the question of its migration westwards to contribute to the peopling of the americas. The kelp highway hypothesis they argue that productive kelp forests supporting similar suites of plants and animals would have existed near the end of the pleistocene. In an earlier discussion of the solutrean hypothesis, bradley and stanford 2004 suggested. Perspective does mitochondrial haplogroup x indicate ancient. Preclovis, younger dryas impact event, solutrean, and the coastal kelp highway. The wellknown beringian land bridge ice free corridor theory was originally put forth on the basis of geological studies of the timing and extent of the great north american glaciers, as well as the lowering of the sea level, as a logical explanation of the peopling of the. Solutrean hypothesis offers the only credible routeexplanation for the unique, substantial presence of west eurasianderived x2g and x2a in the great lakes region of northeast america, and their antiquity oppenheimer et al. Archaeological fantasies and the genetic history of the. According to the solutrean hypothesis, people of the solutrean culture, 21,000 to 17,000 years ago migrated to north america by boat along the pack ice of the north atlantic ocean. While the documentary, the ice bridge, airing as an episode of the nature of things, claims that the solutrean hypothesis is an explosive new theory, the claim that europeans from iberia known as solutreans traveled to north america 20,000 years ago is two decades old. A north american perspective on the volgu biface cache from upper paleolithic france and its relationship to the solutrean hypothesis.
The solutrean hypothesis and its use among modern white. It just isnt actually supported by ancient dna at this point and it is somewhat unlikey this will change. There is a gap of at least 4,000 years between solutrean and clovis. Solutrean that areas of shelf were ice free shaw et. But this primer came in handy when it was time to compare the clovis culture, in the u. The solutrean hypothesis is probably the most controversial hypothesis in academia about how the americas were first populated. My interest in the movie centered mostly around the question of how much, if any, of the storyline would revolve around the central claim of the solutrean hypothesis that late pleistocene europeans colonized eastern north america. Solutrean hypothesis institut fur anglistikamerikanistik. It also sparked a controversy about whether a hypothesis should be. The solutrean hypothesis contrasts with archaeological orthodoxy which. Low this article has been rated as lowimportance on the projects importance scale.
Stanford and bradleys solutrean hypothesis will stimulate additional research and discoveries in the coming decades, and for that we are grateful. Clovis technology with the culture of the solutrean people who occupied france and spain more than 20,000 years ago. The solutrean hypothesis claims that the clovis people, the makers of the earliest known stone tools in the americas, were the cultural and biological descendants of the solutrean peoples of southwest coastal europe. You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. The solutrean hypothesis the alternative hypothesis. Not long after the solutrean hypothesis was proposed, however, archaeologists dismissed the idea with three arguments. The solutrean hypothesis argues that people from europe may have been among the earliest settlers of the americas. Genetics, the mammoth in the room stephen oppenheimer university of oxford institute of social and cultural anthropology school of anthropology and museum ethnography 5153 banbury road oxford ox2 6pe uk bruce bradley university of exeter department of archaeology laver building exeter ex1 1te uk dennis stanford smithsonian institution museum of natural history department.
I think the page should reside under solutrean hypothesis, and have solutrean theory redirect there. The solutrean hypothesis is a legitimate archaeological hypothesis. Skeptic the magazine volume 12 number 3 table of contents. Oct 07, 2010 in the novel, which is entitled white apocalypse, a rogue anthropologist teams up with a proponent of the solutrean hypothesis and a fiery lawyer in order to reveal to the world the shocking truth that carries immense cultural, political, and racial significance. One is postulated to have occurred across a perilous mosaic of periglacial environments of the northern hemisphere during the peak of the last major glaciation some eighteen or twenty millennia ago. Proponents of the solutrean hypothesis assume that there would have been a viable sea ice route in place, and that the solutrean. The science behind why people see ghosts mind altering experiences are one of the foundations of widespread belief in the paranormal.
A rare lineage entering america through the icefre. Mar 03, 2012 the solutrean hypothesis of the first peoples to inhabit north america is getting positively respectable to the point that the washington post has deigned to publish a longish article on the topic radical theory of first americans places stone age europeans in delmarva 20,000 years ago. The solutrean hypothesis sh for the origin of the clovis archaeological culture. Stanford and bruce bradley, suggests that the solutreans, a group of prehistoric spaniards from around 15,000 bce traveled across the atlantic and gave rise to the clovis culture of the americas around 11,000 bce. Edits difficulties with this hypothesis include the challenges of crossing the atlantic with the technology of the time as well as a temporal gap of millennia between the apparent end of the solutrean culture and the earliest discovered clovis tools. Apr 16, 2016 the solutrean hypothesis is a legitimate archaeological hypothesis. The solutrean hypothesis, first put forward in the 1930s and revived more recently by dennis j. The industry first appeared in what is now spain citation needed, and disappears from the archaeological record around 17,000 bp. The solutrean hypothesis on the peopling of the americas claims that the earliest human migration to the americas took place from europe, during the last glacial maximum. The solutrean hypothesis for the origins of the north american clovis. Pdf the solutrean hypothesis for the origin of the clovis archaeological culture.
Solutrean hypothesis open research exeter university of exeter. The solutrean hypothesis is the latest in a long line of theories about the discovery of the new world by jason colavito. The solutrean hypothesis for the origin of the clovis archaeological culture contends that people came from southwestern europe to north. Challenges encountered with this hypothesis is that the solutrean hypothesis has only been around for a short period of time, which means that there is a relatively small amount of evidence has been found on the topic. Its notable recent proponents include dennis stanford of the smithsonian institution and bruce bradley of the university of exeter. Whether you use a 1tailed or 2tailed test depends on the nature of the problem. Since there is little information in the solutrean atlantic hypothesis on the types of boat used, the speed of the proposed migration, or the proportions of time spent on the water versus the ice, we must turn to computer simulations of lgm boat journeys developed by montenegro et al. Its notable proponents include dennis stanford of the smithsonian institution and bruce bradley of the university of exeter.
1506 831 874 1473 775 530 662 449 1600 1404 1064 1284 1743 928 1011 984 1088 266 1196 106 1852